Opus 5.5 vs Astra 6.2: Which Is Better Value, a Claude or an OpenAI Subscription?

Opus 5.5 vs Astra 6.2: Which Is Better Value, a Claude or an OpenAI Subscription?

721 h

Claude Ultra for $200

hours of work one agent gets per month, almost around the clock

828 h

ChatGPT Pro for $200

15% more hours. But Astra works slower, so the number of tasks is about the same: 2,219 vs 2,150

3%

cheaper for a typical task on Astra

not several times, as people say. All 9 tasks together: 72 cents on Opus, 62 on Astra

24/24

coding runs passed the tests

on both models. Quality from two judges is close: 82% for Opus, 86% for Astra

GPT-6.2 Astra came out on November 17, and chats immediately said it was several times cheaper than Claude. We took our own subscriptions, Claude Ultra for $200 and ChatGPT Pro for $100, and ran 9 real work tasks on them overnight. The result: a typical task on Astra is 3% cheaper, all 9 tasks together 13%. Not several times. For the same $200 you fit about the same number of coding tasks.

Measured by Kirill Pukshto, CEO of Section 228, on November 17–18, 2026.

How we tested

The companies don’t say how much work a subscription includes, only the percentage of the weekly limit. At 23:37 Kirill finished work, and we checked that our other chats were idle so the meter would see only our test. 15 agents worked until the weekly meter ticked twice in a row. Everything they used between the ticks is exactly 1% of the week.

We caught a “clean” 1% of the limit and ran 9 tasks

step 1

15

agents work nonstop while our other chats stay idle

step 2

2 ticks

of the weekly meter in a row: 13 → 14 → 15%. Exactly 1% in between

step 3

$22.8

of work at list price = 1% of a Claude Ultra week. On ChatGPT Pro 1% = 155 credits

step 4

9 tasks

from a spending review to long code, each 2–5 times, both models on max

step 5

2 judges

Opus and Astra review the work blind, not knowing whose is whose

November 17–18, 2026, overnight. Claude Code 2.1.319 and Codex CLI 0.169.0, personal Claude Ultra ($200) and ChatGPT Pro ($100) plans.

How many hours of work a subscription gives

A month has 720 hours. The $200 Claude plan gives one agent 721 hours of work, almost around the clock all month. By our estimate the $200 ChatGPT plan gives 828 hours. But Astra worked 13% slower in our runs, so the number of coding tasks is about the same: 2,219 vs 2,150.

For $200: 721 hours of work on Claude, 828 on ChatGPT

Claude · Opus 5.5ChatGPT · Astra 6.2
720 h · around the clock, all month
2,071 h

ChatGPT Pro for $500: almost 3 agents around the clock. Claude has no such plan

Hours = agent working time on our 9 tasks ÷ the share of the week they used; median. Hours depend on speed: Astra worked 13% slower in our runs, so it gets more hours for about the same number of tasks. Measured on Claude Ultra and ChatGPT Pro $100, other plans scaled by multipliers. Accuracy ±20%.

PlanPriceAgent hours per monthLong coding tasks per month
Claude Pro$2072215
ChatGPT Plus$2041111
Claude Max$1003611,075
ChatGPT Pro$1004141,109
Claude Ultra$2007212,150
ChatGPT Pro$2008282,219
ChatGPT Pro$5002,0715,547

Bottom line: at $100 and $200 ChatGPT gives 15% more hours, but about the same number of tasks. At $20 Claude gives almost twice the hours. Only ChatGPT has a $500 plan.

What one task costs

Task price is its share of the weekly limit converted into subscription money. We measured on Claude Ultra and ChatGPT Pro $100.

All 9 tasks: 72 cents of subscription on Opus and 62 on Astra

Opus 5.5 · Claude Ultra $200Astra 6.2 · ChatGPT Pro $100
TaskTask price in subscription moneyCheaper

Review a month of spendingeveryday task, 69 lines

2.4 ¢
1.2 ¢
Astra, 2×

Find 5 booking services for a salonresearch with prices and links

4.3 ¢
4.2 ¢
even

Code review7 planted bugs

4.1 ¢
5.7 ¢
Opus, 1.4×

Find a hidden bugonly the symptom given

3.6 ¢
3.5 ¢
even

Short code, no promptjust the task text

7.9 ¢
7.4 ¢
even

Short code with a prompt1 failing test of 11

6.2 ¢
6.0 ¢
even

Long code task12 failing tests of 31

9.3 ¢
9.0 ¢
even

Coffee shop site, no promptmenu, address, booking

15.2 ¢
14.2 ¢
even

Short code via a pipelineGSD + Superpowers: plan, tests, review

18.5 ¢
10.9 ¢
Astra, 1.7×

Task price = its share of the weekly limit × plan price ÷ 4.3 weeks. Median of 2–5 runs. Accuracy ±20%: “even” means the gap is within the margin. Measured November 17–18, 2026.

Bottom line: Astra is cheaper on 8 of 9 tasks, but noticeably only on the everyday task (2×) and the pipeline (1.7×). Opus is cheaper on code review. A typical task on Astra is 3% cheaper; the 13% across all 9 tasks comes almost entirely from the pipeline. The measurement is accurate to ±20%, so “even” means the gap is within the margin.

Work out your own subscription

Set how many tasks a week you hand to AI and see which plan can take them.

How much of your week will your tasks use

Set how many tasks a week you give to AI. On the right you see how full each plan’s weekly limit gets.

a fix, a feature, a bug
20
find, compare, collect links
20
sort out, calculate, write
30

Claude · Opus 5.5

Claude Pro$20

Claude Max$100

Claude Ultra$200

ChatGPT · Astra 6.2

ChatGPT Plus$20

ChatGPT Pro$100

ChatGPT Pro$200

ChatGPT Pro$500

Based on our measurement at max effort. A coding task counts as our long code task, research as finding 5 services with prices, everyday as a spending review. Five-hour windows are not included.

Which one is smarter and faster

We ran each task 2–5 times. Two blind judges, Opus and Astra, reviewed the first copy of each result without being told whose it was. On coding tasks both models passed the tests in all 24 runs.

Quality from two blind judges: 82% for Opus, 86% for Astra

Quality is the average score of two judges out of 10, times 10. The judges did not know whose work it was. Time: median of runs. In bold: the faster one, and the better one when the gap is 5 points or more.

TaskOpus, minAstra, minOpus, qualityAstra, quality
Monthly spending review5390%75%
Research on salon services71380%95%
Code review, 7 planted bugs101790%95%
Long code task181887.5%85%
Coffee shop site, no prompt333565%90%
Short code, no prompt223080%80%
Short code with a prompt142380%80%
Short code via a pipeline382775%80%
Find a hidden bug5690%90%

Each judge favors its own model: the Opus judge gives Opus 85% and Astra 80%, the Astra judge gives Astra 91% and Opus 79%. That is why there are two judges and we take the average.

We score quality with our own method: each judge rates the work out of 10, we average the two judges and multiply by 10. A gap under 5 points counts as “close”. Opus did better on the spending review: 90% vs 75%, it found all 3 oddities, Astra 2 of 3. Astra did better on research (95% vs 80%, all prices with tax, 2–3 sources each), the site (90% vs 65%), and on review and the pipeline (by 5 points). The other four tasks, the long code task included, came out close.

Bottom line: 82% for Opus and 86% for Astra, a gap under 5 points. Opus was clearly faster on four tasks (research, review, short code with and without a prompt), Astra on two (spending review and pipeline). Astra was measured on release day.

The same site from two models

Code is hard to judge by eye, but a site you see right away. Both models built all 12 menu items, the address and opening hours.

One task, two coffee shop sites

“Build a coffee shop site from menu.json with table booking, check it yourself.” Nothing else, no prompt. The task was in Russian, so the sites are in Russian.

Opus 5.533 minutes · 15 ¢ of subscription
Coffee shop site by Opus: dark hero, menu in three cards, booking form
The same site by Opus on a phone

What the judges noticed · 7 and 6 of 10A neat form: booking times only within opening hours. But it tells the guest “booking received”, while the booking goes nowhere.

Astra 6.235 minutes · 14 ¢ of subscription
Coffee shop site by Astra: cappuccino with a croissant photo, dark green menu, booking form
The same site by Astra on a phone

What the judges noticed · 8 and 10 of 10Made its own photo of coffee and a croissant. Without a server it honestly says “draft”, with a server it saves the booking and avoids duplicates.

Why Astra seems several times cheaper

Astra uses 1.6–5 times fewer tokens for the same task. That is where the talk comes from. But both companies charge the limit roughly by the price of tokens, not by their number. Rereading a long conversation is almost free, while new model text is expensive.

We tripped over this ourselves. Overnight the ChatGPT meter went from 61% to 70%, and Claude only from 13% to 21%, although several more of our chats were running in Claude.

“I sense a catch here”Kirill Pukshto, CEO of Section 228, at 1 a.m.

We checked the logs: overnight the chats read 150 million tokens, almost all from cache, and on the meter that is about 3%. As a share of its own plan, Opus really does burn its limit 2 times slower. But its plan also costs $200 instead of $100.

Lots of tokens, few percent

Overnight our Claude chats read 150 million tokens. Almost all of it is old conversation: the model rereads it on every turn, but from cache. At list price that is 20 times cheaper than normal input, and the limit is charged the same way.

≈3%

of the Ultra week is what those 150M tokens cost. So count the price of tokens, not the tokens

Cross-check on November 18: all chat and test logs for the night against the weekly meter. Price-based forecast 6.8%, meter +6%.

Where you overpay: a pipeline for small fixes

The most expensive line in the table is our own. A short code fix through the GSD + Superpowers pipeline (plan first, then tests, then review) cost three times more on Opus than with a plain prompt: 18.5 cents vs 6.2. Astra got 1.8 times more expensive. For a small fix that way of working turned out to be overpaying; we have not measured it on big tasks yet.

What to buy

  • $20 a month: Claude Pro, almost twice the hours of ChatGPT Plus
  • $100 or $200: ChatGPT gives 15% more hours, about the same number of coding tasks. Everyday reviews are better on Opus, research and “build it from scratch” on Astra
  • need more than $200 gives: ChatGPT Pro for $500, almost 3 agents around the clock. Claude has no such plan
  • running many agents at once: the limit runs out in hours. 15 agents use 1% of the week in 8 minutes. Our Ultra also has a five-hour window, and at that pace it runs out in 3–6 hours

How we measured

  1. Plans: Claude Ultra ($200) and ChatGPT Pro ($100), personal, not business. Tools: Claude Code 2.1.319 and Codex CLI 0.169.0
  2. Models: Claude Opus 5.5 and GPT-6.2 Astra, both at max effort (Astra in Codex also has ultra, which hands work to helpers on its own; we did not use it). No custom rules, memory or plugins, just the task
  3. Calibration: 15 agents nonstop until the weekly meter ticked twice in a row. 1% of an Ultra week = $22.8 of work at Anthropic list price, 1% of a Pro $100 week = 155 Codex credits
  4. Tasks: 9, each run 2–5 times. Task price = its usage at list price ÷ calibration × price of a percent. Hours = working minutes ÷ share of the week, median across tasks
  5. Other plans via multipliers: Claude’s are official (Max 5× Pro, Ultra 10×); ChatGPT’s are our estimate: OpenAI named 5×, 20× and 25× Plus for Pro at $100, $200 and $500 and doubled the Pro $100 and $500 limits on October 29
  6. Cross-check: overnight we added up the logs of all chats and tests and compared them with the meters. Forecast for Claude 6.8% vs +6, for ChatGPT 10.1% vs +9. Including the judges’ usage, Claude accuracy is ±20%
  7. Limitations: one account per company; the meters show whole percentages only; runs of the same task differ up to 2×; the judges saw one copy of 2–5; Astra speed was measured on release day, and hours depend on model speed

FAQ

How many hours of work does a $200 subscription give?

Claude Ultra gives about 721 hours of one agent’s work per month, almost around the clock. By our estimate ChatGPT Pro for $200 gives about 828 hours, but Astra works slower, so the number of tasks is about the same.

Why does the Claude weekly limit run out in two days?

Because of parallel agents. 15 agents use 1% of the week in 8 minutes, so a whole Ultra week is gone in about 13 hours. That is exactly what happened to us in November: we used one and a half weekly limits in a week.

Claude Code or Codex: whose limit runs out first on coding?

As a share of its own plan, Codex on Pro $100 runs out first. In money it is about the same: Pro costs $100, Ultra $200.

Why does a long chat barely use the limit?

The model rereads the old conversation every time, but from cache. At list price that is 20 times cheaper than normal input, and the limit is charged the same way.

Should I pay $100, or is $20 enough?

If AI writes code for you every day, take $100. On $20, Claude gives about 72 hours of agent work per month, ChatGPT about 41.

We’ll work out what AI costs your team

We’ll go through your tasks and pick the plan and model for each, so the limit doesn’t run out by Wednesday.

Get in touch

Measured November 17–18, 2026. We will update it when new models come out or plans change.

Come say hi on social media: Instagram section.228, TikTok @section_228, LinkedIn company/section228

Related stories